Hoshi is an (ISC)2 member who works for the Triffid Corporation as a data manager. Triffid needs a new firewall solution, and Hoshi is asked to recommend a product for Triffid to acquire and implement. Hoshi's cousin works for a firewall vendor; that vendor happens to make the best firewall available. What should Hoshi do? (D1, L1.5.1)
D is the best answer. According to the third Canon of the ISC2 Code of Ethics, members are required to "provide diligent and competent service to principals." Hoshi's principal here is Triffid, Hoshi's employer. It would be inappropriate for Hoshi to select the cousin's product solely based upon the family relationship; however, if the cousin's product is, in fact, the best choice for Triffid, then Hoshi should recommend that product. In order to avoid any appearance of impropriety or favoritism, Hoshi needs to declare the relationship when making the recommendation.
D is the best answer. According to the third Canon of the ISC2 Code of Ethics, members are required to "provide diligent and competent service to principals." Hoshi's principal here is Triffid, Hoshi's employer. It would be inappropriate for Hoshi to select the cousin's product solely based upon the family relationship; however, if the cousin's product is, in fact, the best choice for Triffid, then Hoshi should recommend that product. In order to avoid any appearance of impropriety or favoritism, Hoshi needs to declare the relationship when making the recommendation.